| title | artist | year | album |
| I Ain’t Gonna Give Nobody None o’ This Jelly Roll | Dabney’s Novelty Band | 1919 | After Midnight |
| I Ain’t Gonna Give Nobody None O’This Jellyroll | Wilbur Sweatman’s Original Jazz Band | 1919 | Jazzin' Straight Thru' Paradise |
| I Ain’t Gonna Tell Nobody | King Oliver’s Jazz Band | 1923 | Centennial |
| I Ain’t Got Nobody Much | Marion Harris | 1916 | The Complete Victor Releases |
| I Ain’t Got Nobody Much | Marion Harris | 1916 | 1917: "Yankees to the Ranks" |
| I Ain’t Had No Lovin’ in a Long Time | Bob Roberts | 1908 | The Product of Our Souls |
| I Herrens helgedom | Folke Andersson | 1927 | Swede Home Chicago |
| I ljuva drömmar | Scandinavian Bell Ringers | 1925 | Swede Home Chicago |
| I’ve Got the Finest Man | Ada Jones | 1912 | The Product of Our Souls |
| I Am Praying for You | Steve Porter | 1900 | Waxing the Gospel: Mass Evangelism and the Phonograph, 1890-1900 |
| I Apologize | Phil Spitalny’s Orchestra | 1931 | The Complete Hit of the Week Recordings, Volume 3 |
| I Beg Your Pardon, Mademoiselle | Andy Sannella and His Orchestra | 1932 | The Complete Hit of the Week Recordings, Volume 4 |
| I Call You Sunshine | Art Hickman’s Orchestra | 1921 | The San Francisco Sound, Volume 2 |
| I Can Dance with Everybody but My Wife | Joseph Cawthorn | 1916 | 1916: "The Country Found Them Ready" |
| I Can’t Sleep in the Movies Anymore | Arthur Fields and his Assassinators | 1929 | Anthology: Singer, Songwriter, Soldier |
| I Certainly Was Going Some | Bert Williams | 1913 | The Middle Years, 1910-1918 |
| I Couldn’t Hear Nobody Pray | Fisk University Jubilee Quartet | 1909 | There Breathes a Hope: The Legacy of John Work II and His Fisk Jubilee Quartet, 1909-1916 |
| I Couldn’t Hear Nobody Pray | Fisk University Jubilee Quartet | 1916 | There Breathes a Hope: The Legacy of John Work II and His Fisk Jubilee Quartet, 1909-1916 |
| I Didn’t Raise My Boy to be a Soldier | Morton Harvey | 1915 | The Great War: An American Musical Fantasy |
| I Didn’t Raise My Boy to Be a Soldier | Morton Harvey | 1915 | 1915: "They'd Sooner Sleep on Thistles" |
| I Didn’t Raise My Boy to Be a Soldier | Peerless Quartette | 1915 | 1915: "They'd Sooner Sleep on Thistles" |
| I Don’t Care | Guido Deiro | ca. 1913 | Complete Recorded Works, Volume 2 |
| I Don’t Know and I Don’t Care Blues | Edith Wilson and Her Jazz Band | 1924 | "Ain't Gonna Settle Down": The Pioneering Blues of Mary Stafford and Edith Wilson |
| I Don’t Know Where I’m Going but I’m on My Way | Peerless Quartet | 1917 | The Great War: An American Musical Fantasy |
| I Don’t Know Where I’m Going but I’m on My Way | Peerless Quartet | 1917 | 1918: "Like the Sunshine After Rain" |
| I Don’t Like that Face You Wear [10 inch disc] | Bert Williams and George Walker | 1901 | The Early Years, 1901-1909 |
| I Don’t Like that Face You Wear [7 inch disc] | Bert Williams and George Walker | 1901 | The Early Years, 1901-1909 |
| I Don’t Think I Need a Job that Bad | Gus Van | 1917 | Pennant-Winning Battery of Songland |
| I Don’t Want Nobody Blues | Edith Wilson and Johnny Dunn’s Original Jazz Hounds | 1921 | "Ain't Gonna Settle Down": The Pioneering Blues of Mary Stafford and Edith Wilson |
| I Don’t Want to Get Well | Gus Van and Joe Schenck | 1917 | Pennant-Winning Battery of Songland |
| I Don’t Want to Get Well | Gus Van and Joe Schenck | 1917 | 1918: "Like the Sunshine After Rain" |
| I Due Ladri e l’Asino | Anonymous | 1890-95 | Etching the Voice |
| I Faw Down and Go Boom! | Midnight Ramblers with vocal chorus by Billy Murray | 1928 | Anthology: The Denver Nightingale |
| I Found A Million Dollar Baby | Don Voorhees’ Orchestra | 1931 | The Complete Hit of the Week Recordings, Volume 3 |
| I Got to See the Minstrel Show | Arthur Collins | 1906 | At the Minstrel Show |
| I Guess I’ll Have to Telegraph My Baby | Edward M. Favor | 1899 | The 1890s, Vol. 1: "Wipe Him Off the Land" |
| I Just Can’t Make My Eyes Behave | Ada Jones | 1907 | 1907: "Dear Old Golden Rule Days" |
| I Know the Lord Laid His Hands on Me | Fisk University Jubilee Quartet | 1911 | There Breathes a Hope: The Legacy of John Work II and His Fisk Jubilee Quartet, 1909-1916 |
| I Left Her on the Beach at Honolulu | W. G. Haenschen’s Banjo Orchestra | 1916 | The Missing Link |
| I Like the Hat, I Like the Dress, and I Like the Girl that’s in It | Byron G. Harlan | 1911 | 1911: "Up, Up a Little Bit Higher" |
| I Like You Best of All | Joseph C. Smith’s Orchestra | 1925 | Songs of the Night |
| I Lost My Heart to You | Joseph C. Smith’s Orchestra | 1921 | Songs of the Night |
| I Love a Lassie | Harry Lauder | 1905 | 1907: "Dear Old Golden Rule Days" |
| I Love a Piano | Billy Murray | 1916 | Anthology: The Denver Nightingale |
| I Love a Piano | Billy Murray | 1916 | 1916: "The Country Found Them Ready" |
| I Love Her, Oh, Oh, Oh! | Guido Deiro and Pietro Deiro | 1913 | Complete Recorded Works, Volume 2 |
| I Love Her-She Loves Me (I’m Her He-She’s My She) | Eddie Cantor | 1922 | 1922: "An Angel's Voice I Hear" |
| I Love, I Love, I Love My Wife, But Oh You Kid | Arthur Collins | 1909 | 1909: "Talk of Your Scand'lous Times" |
| I Love the Ladies | Arthur Collins and Byron Harlan | 1914 | 1914: "Her Memory Haunts You" |
| I Love the Ladies | Irving Kaufman | 1914 | Anthology: The Last Recording Pioneer |
| I Love the Name of Mary | Will Oakland | 1910 | 1911: "Up, Up a Little Bit Higher" |
| I Love Them All a Little Bit | Elsie Janis | 1918 | Sweetheart of the A.E.F. |
| I Love You So | Harry Macdonough and Elise Stevenson | 1907 | 1908: "Take Me Out with the Crowd" |
| I Love You Sunday | The Benson Orchestra of Chicago | 1920 | The Benson Orchestra of Chicago, 1920-1921 |
| I Love You Sunday | Isham Jones Rainbo Orchestra | 1920 | The Missing Link |
| I Love You Truly | Elsie Baker | 1912 | 1912: "Waitin' on the Levee" |
| I Love You, Sunday | Isham Jones Rainbo Orchestra | 1920 | Happy: The 1920 Rainbo Orchestra Sides |
| I Loved You Better Than You Knew | Arthur Collins and Byron Harlan | ca. 1902-03 | Anthology: America's Favorite Entertainers |
| I May Be Crazy, but I Ain’t No Fool | Bob Roberts | 1904 | 1904: "Call It the Land of Dreams" |
| I May Be Gone for a Long, Long Time | Shannon Four | 1917 | 1917: "Yankees to the Ranks" |
| I Miss the Old Folks Now | Gus Van and Joe Schenck | 1917 | Pennant-Winning Battery of Songland |
| I Moschettieri (The Musketeers) | Guido Deiro | ca. 1925-1926 | Complete Recorded Works, Volume 4 |
| I Never Realized | Isham Jones Orchestra | 1920 | Happy: The 1920 Rainbo Orchestra Sides |
| I Pagliacci (Vesti la Giubba) | Guido Deiro | 1917 | Complete Recorded Works, Volume 3 |
| I Sent My Wife to the Thousand Isles | Al Jolson | 1916 | 1916: "The Country Found Them Ready" |
| I Spoiled You | Art Hickman’s Orchestra | 1921 | The San Francisco Sound, Volume 2 |
| I Still Get A Thrill | Hotel Pennsylvania Orchestra | 1930 | The Complete Hit of the Week Recordings, Volume 1 |
| I Surrender All | Daisy Tapley and Carroll Clark | 1910 | Lost Sounds: Blacks and the Birth of the Recording Industry, 1891-1922 |
| I Surrender All | Winfield S. Weeden and chorus | 1897 | Waxing the Gospel: Mass Evangelism and the Phonograph, 1890-1900 |
| I Surrender, Dear | Sam Lanin’s Dance Ensemble | 1931 | The Complete Hit of the Week Recordings, Volume 2 |
| I Thought I Was a Winner, or, I Don’t Know, You Ain’t So Warm | Columbia Orchestra | ca. 1897 | Stomp and Swerve: American Music Gets Hot |
| I Used to Love You but It’s All Over Now | Frank Crumit | 1921 | 1921: "Make Believe and Smile" |
| I Wanna Sing About You | Hit of the Week Orchestra | 1931 | The Complete Hit of the Week Recordings, Volume 2 |
| I Want a Dancing Man | Elsie Janis | 1914 | Sweetheart of the A.E.F. |
| I Want a Girl Just Like the Girl that Married Dear Old Dad | American Quartet | 1911 | 1911: "Up, Up a Little Bit Higher" |
| I Want to Be a Soldier Like My Dad | Robert Lewis | 1918 | The Great War: An American Musical Fantasy |
| I Want to Go Back to the Farm | Elida Morris | 1914 | 1914: "Her Memory Haunts You" |
| I Want to Go to Morrow | Dan W. Quinn | 1901 | Anthology: The King of Comic Singers, 1894-1917 |
| I Want to Know Where Tosti Went | Bert Williams | 1920 | His Final Releases, 1919-1922 |
| I Want to Love You While the Music’s Playing | Heidelberg Quintet | 1912 | Floating Down the River |
| I Want to Love You While the Music’s Playing | Heidelberg Quintet | 1912 | Floating Down the River |
| I Wasn’t Skeared But I Thought I’d Better Go | Gus Van | 1916 | Pennant-Winning Battery of Songland |
| I Wish I Could Shimmy Like My Sister Kate | The Georgians | 1922 | Centennial |
| I Wish I Could Shimmy Like My Sister Kate | The Virginians | 1922 | The Moaninest Moan of Them All |
| I Wish I Could Shimmy Like My Sister Kate | The Virginians | 1922 | 1923: "Gonna Play the Villain Part" |
| I Wish I Had a Girl | Harry Tally | ca. 1908-1909 | 1909: "Talk of Your Scand'lous Times" |
| I Wonder Where My Baby Is To-Night? | Henry Burr and Billy Murray | 1925 | Anthology: The Original King of Pop |
| I Wonder Who’s Kissing Her Now | Henry Burr | 1909 | Anthology: The Original King of Pop |
| I Wonder Who’s Kissing Her Now | Henry Burr | 1909 | 1909: "Talk of Your Scand'lous Times" |
| I Wonder Why | Marion Harris and Billy Murray | 1917 | The Complete Victor Releases |
| I Won’t Be Back Till August | Eddie Morton | 1910 | The Sound of Vaudeville, Vol. 1 |
| I Work Eight Hours, Sleep Eight Hours, That Leaves Eight Hours for Love | Nora Bayes | 1914 | Together and Alone |
| I’d Feel at Home if They’d Let Me Join the Army | Billy Murray | 1917 | The Great War: An American Musical Fantasy |
| I’d Leave My Happy Home for You | Arthur Collins | 1899 | The 1890s, Vol. 1: "Wipe Him Off the Land" |
| I’d Love to Fall Asleep and Wake Up in My Mammy’s Arms | The Benson Orchestra of Chicago | 1920 | The Benson Orchestra of Chicago, 1920-1921 |
| I’d Rather Be a Minstrel Man than a Multimillionaire | Eddie Morton | 1909 | The Sound of Vaudeville, Vol. 1 |
| I’d Rather Two-Step than Waltz, Bill | Clarice Vance | 1907 | The High Priestess of Jollity & The Southern Singer |
| Ida | Erno Rapee’s Orchestra | 1932 | The Complete Hit of the Week Recordings, Volume 4 |
| Ida, Sweet as Apple Cider | Eddie Leonard | ca. 1940 | Monarchs of Minstrelsy |
| Idle Dreams | Isham Jones Rainbo Orchestra | 1920 | Happy: The 1920 Rainbo Orchestra Sides |
| If a Table at Rector’s Could Talk | Nat M. Wills | 1913 | The Famous Tramp Comedian |
| If a Wish Could Make It So | Art Hickman’s Orchestra | 1920 | The San Francisco Sound, Volume 2 |
| If a Wish Could Make It So | Six Brown Brothers | 1920 | Those Moaning Saxophones |
| If Anybody Wants to Meet a Jonah, Shake Hands with Me | Clarice Vance | 1906 | The High Priestess of Jollity & The Southern Singer |
| If He Can Fight Like He Can Love (Good Night, Germany) | Farber Sisters | 1918 | The Great War: An American Musical Fantasy |
| If He Comes In, I’m Going Out | Eddie Morton | 1910 | The Sound of Vaudeville, Vol. 1 |
| If I Could Be With You One Hour To-night | Hit of the Week Orchestra | 1930 | The Complete Hit of the Week Recordings, Volume 2 |
| If I Could See as Far Ahead as I Can See Behind | Eddie Morton | 1910 | The Sound of Vaudeville, Vol. 1 |
| If I Had A Girl Like You | Phil Spitalny’s Music | 1930 | The Complete Hit of the Week Recordings, Volume 1 |
| If I Knock the “L” Out of Kelly | Marguerite Farrell | 1916 | 1916: "The Country Found Them Ready" |
| If I Was as Strong as Samson | Gus Van | 1917 | Pennant-Winning Battery of Songland |
| If I’m Going to Die I’m Going to Have Some Fun | Arthur Collins | 1907 | 1907: "Dear Old Golden Rule Days" |
| If We Can’t Be the Same Old Sweethearts, We’ll Just Be the Same Old Friends | Irving Kaufman | 1915 | 1915: "They'd Sooner Sleep on Thistles" |
| If You Don’t Want Me Send Me to My Ma | Mary Stafford and Her Jazz Band | 1921 | "Ain't Gonna Settle Down": The Pioneering Blues of Mary Stafford and Edith Wilson |
| If You Talk in Your Sleep, Don’t Mention My Name | Billy Murray | 1911 | 1912: "Waitin' on the Levee" |
| Il Lido | Guido Deiro | ca. 1925-1926 | Complete Recorded Works, Volume 4 |
| Il Pentimento (Repentance) | Guido Deiro | ca. 1925-1926 | Complete Recorded Works, Volume 4 |
| Il Pianto | Guido Deiro | ca. 1913 | Complete Recorded Works, Volume 2 |
| Il Ritorno de Pietro (Pietro’s Return) | Guido Deiro | ca. 1925-1926 | Complete Recorded Works, Volume 4 |
| Il Trovatore | Guido Deiro | ca. 1911 | Complete Recorded Works, Volume 1 |
| Il Trovatore | Unknown | ca. 1892-94 | Masters of the Clarinet, 1892-1920 |
| I’ll Be Blue Just Thinking Of You | Hit of the Week Orchestra | 1930 | The Complete Hit of the Week Recordings, Volume 2 |
| I’ll Be With You in Apple Blossom Time | Charles Harrison | 1920 | 1920: "Even Water's Getting Weaker" |
| I’ll Build a Stairway to Paradise | Markels’ Orchestra | 1922 | The Moaninest Moan of Them All |
| I’ll Build a Stairway to Paradise | Paul Whiteman’s Orchestra | 1922 | 1923: "Gonna Play the Villain Part" |
| I’ll Get Even with You | Edith Wilson | 1930 | "Ain't Gonna Settle Down": The Pioneering Blues of Mary Stafford and Edith Wilson |
| I’ll Go Where You Want Me to Go | Ira D. Sankey | 1900 | Waxing the Gospel: Mass Evangelism and the Phonograph, 1890-1900 |
| I’ll Keep on Loving You | Guido Deiro | 1921 | Complete Recorded Works, Volume 3 |
| I’ll Keep On Loving You | The Benson Orchestra of Chicago | 1921 | The Benson Orchestra of Chicago, 1920-1921 |
| I’ll Lend You Anything | Bert Williams | 1910 | The Middle Years, 1910-1918 |
| I’ll Make a Ring Around Rosie | Haydn Quartet | 1910 | 1910: "Act Two, Scene New" |
| I’ll Say She Does | Al Jolson | 1918 | 1919: "Jazzin' Around and Paintin' the Town" |
| I’ll Say She Does | Six Brown Brothers | 1919 | Those Moaning Saxophones |
| I’ll Say She Does | Wilbur Sweatman’s Original Jazz Band | 1919 | Jazzin' Straight Thru' Paradise |
| I’ll See You in C-u-b-a | Billy Murray | 1920 | 1920: "Even Water's Getting Weaker" |
| I’m a Member of the Midnight Crew | Eddie Morton | 1909 | The Sound of Vaudeville, Vol. 1 |
| I’m Afraid to Come Home in the Dark | Clarice Vance | 1908 | The High Priestess of Jollity & The Southern Singer |
| I’m Afraid to Come Home in the Dark | Billy Murray | 1907 | 1908: "Take Me Out with the Crowd" |
| I’m Afraid, Pretty Maid, I’m Afraid | Ada Jones and Walter Van Brunt | 1912 | 1912: "Waitin' on the Levee" |
| I’m All Bound ‘Round with the Mason Dixon Line | Al Jolson | 1917 | 1918: "Like the Sunshine After Rain" |
| I’m All Bound ‘Round with the Mason Dixon Line | Irving Kaufman | 1917 | Anthology: The Last Recording Pioneer |
| I’m Always Chasing Rainbows | Charles Harrison | 1918 | 1918: "Like the Sunshine After Rain" |
| I’m Crazy ‘Bout the Turkey Trot | Arthur Collins and Byron Harlan | 1911 | Anthology: America's Favorite Entertainers |
| I’m Crying Just for You | Eddie Morton | 1913 | Ed. Morton's "Bit of Broadway" |
| I’m Dreaming of You | Arthur Collins and Byron Harlan | 1905 | Anthology: America's Favorite Entertainers |
| I’m Falling in Love with Some One | John McCormack | 1911 | 1911: "Up, Up a Little Bit Higher" |
| I’m Following You | Ben Pollack Orchestra | 1930 | The Complete Hit of the Week Recordings, Volume 1 |
| I’m Forever Blowing Bubbles | Albert Campbell and Henry Burr | 1919 | Anthology: The Original King of Pop |
| I’m Forever Blowing Bubbles | Albert Campbell and Henry Burr | 1919 | 1919: "Jazzin' Around and Paintin' the Town" |
| I’m Forever Blowing Bubbles | Selvin’s Novelty Orchestra | 1919 | 1919: "Jazzin' Around and Paintin' the Town" |
| I’m Glad My Daddy’s in a Uniform | Sophie Tucker and Her Five Kings of Syncopation | 1918 | Origins of the Red Hot Mama, 1910-1922 |
| I’m Going Away to Wear You Off My Mind | King Oliver’s Creole Jazz Band | 1923 | Centennial |
| I’m Going Away to Wear You Off My Mind | Original Memphis Five | 1922 | Centennial |
| I’m Going Back to Dixie | Arthur Collins and Byron Harlan | 1911 | 1912: "Waitin' on the Levee" |
| I’m Going to Follow the Boys | Elizabeth Spencer and Henry Burr | 1917 | The Great War: An American Musical Fantasy |
| I’m Gone Before I Go | Bert Williams | 1916 | The Middle Years, 1910-1918 |
| I’m Gonna Jazz My Way Right Straight Thru Paradise | Mary Stafford and Her Jazz Band | 1921 | "Ain't Gonna Settle Down": The Pioneering Blues of Mary Stafford and Edith Wilson |
| I’m Gonna Make Hay While the Sun Shines in Virginia | Marion Harris | 1916 | The Complete Victor Releases |
| I’m Gonna Quit Saturday | Bert Williams | 1920 | His Final Releases, 1919-1922 |
| I’m in Love | Gus Van | 1918 | Pennant-Winning Battery of Songland |
| I’m Just A Dancing Sweetheart | Freddie Rich’s Radio Orchestra | 1931 | The Complete Hit of the Week Recordings, Volume 3 |
| I’m Just Wild About Harry | Vaughn De Leath | 1922 | 1922: "An Angel's Voice I Hear" |
| I’m Just Wild About Harry | Lanin’s Southern Serenaders | 1922 | The Moaninest Moan of Them All |
| I’m Keepin’ Company | Hit of the Week Orchestra | 1931 | The Complete Hit of the Week Recordings, Volume 3 |
| I’m Neutral | Bert Williams | 1915 | The Middle Years, 1910-1918 |
| I’m Not Prepared | Elsie Janis | 1916 | Sweetheart of the A.E.F. |
| I’m Old but I’m Awfully Tough | Cal Stewart | 1901 | The 1890s, Vol. 1: "Wipe Him Off the Land" |
| I’m Old but I’m Awfully Tough | Cal Stewart | 1909 | The Indestructible Uncle Josh |
| I’m on My Way to Mandalay | Oakland?Campbell?Burr | 1913 | 1914: "Her Memory Haunts You" |
| I’m So Alone With the Crowd | Morton Downey and Orchestra | 1932 | The Complete Hit of the Week Recordings, Volume 4 |
| I’m Sorry I Ain’t Got It | Bert Williams | 1919 | His Final Releases, 1919-1922 |
| I’m Sorry I Made You Cry | Henry Burr | 1918 | 1918: "Like the Sunshine After Rain" |
| I’m Thru With Love | Don Voorhees Orchestra | 1931 | The Complete Hit of the Week Recordings, Volume 2 |
| I’m Tired of Eating in the Restaurants [10 in. disc] | Bert Williams | 1906 | The Early Years, 1901-1909 |
| I’m Tired of Eating in the Restaurants [2 min. cylinder] | Bert Williams | ca. 1906-07 | The Early Years, 1901-1909 |
| I’m Wearing My Heart Away for You | Columbia Minstrels (feat. George J. Gaskin) | 1903 | At the Minstrel Show |
| I’m Wise | Clarice Vance | 1907 | The High Priestess of Jollity & The Southern Singer |
| I’m Wise | Clarice Vance | 1907 | 1908: "Take Me Out with the Crowd" |
| I’m Yours | Benrus Radio Orchestra | 1930 | The Complete Hit of the Week Recordings, Volume 2 |
| Im Frühjahr | Charles Schoenenberger | ca. 1920-1921 | Alpine Dreaming |
| Imitations | Elsie Janis | 1939 | Sweetheart of the A.E.F. |
| Immortality | William Jennings Bryan | 1908 | Debate '08: Taft and Bryan Campaign on the Edison Phonograph |
| Imperialism | William Jennings Bryan | 1908 | Debate '08: Taft and Bryan Campaign on the Edison Phonograph |
| Important Information [ad for Chevrolet] | Phil Spitalny’s Music | 1932 | The Complete Hit of the Week Recordings, Volume 4 |
| Important News From Westinghouse | Unknown | 1931 | The Complete Hit of the Week Recordings, Volume 3 |
| In Apple Blossom Time (Down on the Farm) | Heidelberg Quintet | 1913 | Floating Down the River |
| In Bright Mansions Above | Fisk University Jubilee Quartet | 1911 | There Breathes a Hope: The Legacy of John Work II and His Fisk Jubilee Quartet, 1909-1916 |
| In Coonland | London Concert Orchestra | 1902 | The Pink Lambert: A Collection of the First Celluloid Cylinders |
| In Dear Old Georgia | Haydn Quartet | 1905 | 1905: "Deliver Daniel From the Lion's Den" |
| In Ireland | Eddie Morton | 1909 | The Sound of Vaudeville, Vol. 1 |
| In Lover’s Lane | Arthur Pryor’s Band | 1908 | Echoes from Asbury Park |
| In My Castle on the River Nile [10 in. disc] | Bert Williams | 1901 | The Early Years, 1901-1909 |
| In My Merry Oldsmobile | Billy Murray | 1905 | Anthology: The Denver Nightingale |
| In My Merry Oldsmobile | Billy Murray | 1906 | 1905: "Deliver Daniel From the Lion's Den" |
| In That City | Rittersville Children’s Chorus | ca. 1898-1900 | Waxing the Gospel: Mass Evangelism and the Phonograph, 1890-1900 |
| In that Great Gettin’ Up Mawnin’ | Fisk University Jubilee Quartet | 1916 | There Breathes a Hope: The Legacy of John Work II and His Fisk Jubilee Quartet, 1909-1916 |
| In the Baggage Coach Ahead | Steve Porter | ca. 1899 | The 1890s, Vol. 1: "Wipe Him Off the Land" |
| In the Garden of My Heart | Frank C. Stanley and Henry Burr | 1909 | 1909: "Talk of Your Scand'lous Times" |
| In the Gloaming | Roger Harding | 1897 | The 1890s, Vol. 1: "Wipe Him Off the Land" |
| In the Gloaming | Will Oakland and the American Quartet | 1910 | Floating Down the River |
| In the Good Old Summer Time | Harry Macdonough | 1902 | The Pink Lambert: A Collection of the First Celluloid Cylinders |
| In the Good Old Summer Time | William Redmond | ca. 1902 | Monarchs of Minstrelsy |
| In the Good Old Summertime | Irving Kaufman | 1946 | Anthology: The Last Recording Pioneer |
| In the Heart of the Kentucky Hills | Heidelberg Quintet | 1913 | Floating Down the River |
| In the Land O’ Yamo Yamo [version 1] | Gus Van and Joe Schenck | 1917 | Pennant-Winning Battery of Songland |
| In the Land O’ Yamo Yamo [version 2] | Gus Van and Joe Schenck | 1918 | Pennant-Winning Battery of Songland |
| In the Land of Harmony and “Stop Stop Stop” | Guido Deiro | ca. 1911 | Complete Recorded Works, Volume 1 |
| In the Land of Harmony and Stop Stop Stop (medley) | Guido Deiro | 1912 | 1912: "Waitin' on the Levee" |
| In the Little Red School House | Billy Jones and Ernest Hare | 1922 | 1922: "An Angel's Voice I Hear" |
| In the Morning | Fisk University Jubilee Quartet | 1911 | There Breathes a Hope: The Legacy of John Work II and His Fisk Jubilee Quartet, 1909-1916 |
| In the Right Church but in the Wrong Pew | Eddie Morton | 1908 | The Sound of Vaudeville, Vol. 1 |
| In the Shade of the Old Apple Tree | Irving Gillette | 1905 | Anthology: The Original King of Pop |
| In the Shade of the Old Apple Tree | Irving Gillette | 1905 | 1905: "Deliver Daniel From the Lion's Den" |
| In The Shade Of The Old Apple Tree | Phil Spitalny’s Music | 1931 | The Complete Hit of the Week Recordings, Volume 3 |
| In the Shadow of the Pyramid | Frank C. Stanley | 1904 | 1905: "Deliver Daniel From the Lion's Den" |
| In the Sweet By and By | Anonymous | 1890 | Waxing the Gospel: Mass Evangelism and the Phonograph, 1890-1900 |
| In the Sweet By-and-By | Anonymous | 1890-95 | Etching the Voice |
| In the Valley of the Moon | Helen Clark and Henry Burr | 1914 | 1914: "Her Memory Haunts You" |
| In the Valley of Yesterday | Harry Macdonough | 1909 | 1910: "Act Two, Scene New" |
| In Zanzibar | Emma Carus | 1904 | 1904: "Call It the Land of Dreams" |
| Independentia and Billboard Medley March | Five Brown Brothers | 1911 | Broadway's Favorite Clowns |
| Independentia-Medley March | Six Brown Brothers | 1915 | Broadway's Favorite Clowns |
| Indiana | Sterling Trio | 1917 | 1917: "Yankees to the Ranks" |
| Indianola | Billy Murray | 1918 | The Great War: An American Musical Fantasy |
| Indianola | Wilbur Sweatman’s Original Jazz Band | 1918 | Jazzin' Straight Thru' Paradise |
| Indigo Blues | Dabney’s Band | 1919 | After Midnight |
| Indoor Sports | Bert Williams | 1915 | The Middle Years, 1910-1918 |
| Inflammatus from Stabat Mater | Bohumir Kryl | ca. 1901 | World-Famous Wizard of the Cornet |
| Ingalill | Knut Öhrström | 1924 | Swede Home Chicago |
| Insurance Scene | Joe Weber and Lew Fields | 1912 | The Mike and Meyer Files |
| The International Rag | Arthur Collins and Byron Harlan | 1913 | Real Ragtime: Disc Recordings From Its Heyday |
| The International Rag | Arthur Collins and Byron Harlan | 1913 | 1914: "Her Memory Haunts You" |
| Interview/Under the Japanese Moon | Irving Caesar and Gus Haenschen/Gus Haenschen | 1975 | The Missing Link |
| Introductory Overture | Columbia Minstrels (Entire Company) | 1903 | At the Minstrel Show |
| Ireland Must Be Heaven for My Mother Came from There | Charles Harrison | 1916 | 1916: "The Country Found Them Ready" |
| Irish Fantaisie | Bohumir Kryl | ca. 1918 | World-Famous Wizard of the Cornet |
| Irish Humor | William Howard Taft | 1908 | Debate '08: Taft and Bryan Campaign on the Edison Phonograph |
| Irish Washerwoman Medley | Unknown Harmonica Player | 1901 | Before the Big Bang |
| Is There Still Room for Me Neath the Old Apple Tree | Albert Campbell and Henry Burr | 1915 | 1916: "The Country Found Them Ready" |
| Isch-Ka-Bibble (I Should Worry) | Eddie Morton | 1913 | Ed. Morton's "Bit of Broadway" |
| I’se Gwine Back to Dixie | Edison Quartet | ca. 1897-98 | The 1890s, Vol. 2: "Wear Yer Bran' New Gown" |
| I’se Gwine Back to Dixie | The Unique Quartette | ca. 1895-1896 | Celebrated, 1895-1896 |
| It Ain’t Gonna Rain No Mo! | Joseph C. Smith and His Mount Royal Orchestra | 1924 | Songs of the Night |
| It Looks to Me Like a Big Night Tonight | Clarice Vance | 1909 | The High Priestess of Jollity & The Southern Singer |
| It Looks Like a Big Night To-Night | Clarice Vance | 1909 | 1909: "Talk of Your Scand'lous Times" |
| It Must Be Someone Like You | The Benson Orchestra of Chicago | 1921 | The Benson Orchestra of Chicago, 1920-1921 |
| Italian Army March | Guido Deiro | ca. 1911 | Complete Recorded Works, Volume 1 |
| Italian Street Song | Lucy Isabelle Marsh with Victor Light Opera Company | 1910 | 1911: "Up, Up a Little Bit Higher" |
| It’s a Long Lane that Has No Turning | Columbia Quartet | 1911 | 1912: "Waitin' on the Levee" |
| It’s a Long, Long Time Since I’ve Been Home | Gus Van and Joe Schenck | 1916 | Pennant-Winning Battery of Songland |
| It’s a Long, Long Way to Tipperary | American Quartet | 1914 | 1914: "Her Memory Haunts You" |
| It’s a Long, Long Way to Tipperary | American Quartet | 1914 | The Great War: An American Musical Fantasy |
| It’s a Long, Long Way to Tipperary | John McCormack with Male Chorus | 1914 | 1915: "They'd Sooner Sleep on Thistles" |
| It’s a Long, Long Way to Tipperary | John McCormack & Male Chorus | 1914 | Centennial |
| It’s a Long Way to Berlin, but We’ll Get There! | Arthur Fields | 1917 | Anthology: Singer, Songwriter, Soldier |
| It’s All Over Now | Sophie Tucker and Her Five Kings of Syncopation | 1920 | Origins of the Red Hot Mama, 1910-1922 |
| It’s Gonna Be a Cold, Cold Winter | Edith Wilson and “Doc” Straine | 1925 | "Ain't Gonna Settle Down": The Pioneering Blues of Mary Stafford and Edith Wilson |
| It’s Got to Be a Minstrel Show Tonight | Dan W. Quinn | 1902 | At the Minstrel Show |
| It’s Nobody’s Business But My Own | Bert Williams | 1919 | His Final Releases, 1919-1922 |
| It’s Nobody’s Business but My Own | Bert Williams | 1919 | 1919: "Jazzin' Around and Paintin' the Town" |
| It’s Not Your Nationality (It’s Simply You) | Dan W. Quinn | 1916 | Anthology: The King of Comic Singers, 1894-1917 |
| It’s The Girl | Freddie Rich’s Radio Orchestra | 1931 | The Complete Hit of the Week Recordings, Volume 3 |
| It’s the Same Old Shillelagh | Harry’s Tavern Band with Billy Murray | 1940 | Anthology: The Denver Nightingale |
| It’s Tulip Time in Holland (Two Lips Are Calling Me) | Harry Macdonough | 1915 | 1915: "They'd Sooner Sleep on Thistles" |
| It’s You | Joseph C. Smith’s Orchestra | 1921 | Songs of the Night |
| I’ve a Shooting Box in Scotland | Joseph C. Smith’s Orchestra | 1917 | Songs of the Night |
| I’ve Got a Feelin’ for You | Arthur Collins | 1904 | 1904: "Call It the Land of Dreams" |
| I’ve Got Everything I Want But You | Elsie Janis and Basil Hallam | 1914 | Sweetheart of the A.E.F. |
| I’ve Got My Captain Working for Me Now | Al Jolson | 1919 | 1920: "Even Water's Getting Weaker" |
| I’ve Got My Habits On | Bailey’s Lucky Seven | 1921 | The Moaninest Moan of Them All |
| I’ve Got Rings on My Fingers | Ada Jones | 1909 | 1909: "Talk of Your Scand'lous Times" |
| I’ve Got Rings on My Fingers | Blanche Ring | 1909 | 1909: "Talk of Your Scand'lous Times" |
| I’ve Got the Time, I’ve Got the Place, But It’s Hard to Find the Girl | Henry Burr | 1910 | Anthology: The Original King of Pop |
| I’ve Got You, Steve! | Eddie Morton | 1912 | Ed. Morton's "Bit of Broadway" |
| I’ve Lost My Heart to the Meanest Girl in Town | Mary Stafford and Her Jazz Band | 1921 | "Ain't Gonna Settle Down": The Pioneering Blues of Mary Stafford and Edith Wilson |
| I’ve Such a Funny Feeling When I Look at You [10 in. disc] | Bert Williams | 1906 | The Early Years, 1901-1909 |
| I’ve Such a Funny Feeling When I Look at You [unissued 10 in. disc] | Bert Williams | 1906 | The Early Years, 1901-1909 |